Town of Provincetown

Meeting of the

Water & Sewer Board

 

Thursday, July 12, 2007

Grace Gouveia Building, 26 Alden Street, Provincetown

 

Members present:  Jonathan Sinaiko, Chair; Sacha Richter, Moe Van Dereck (joined the meeting at 3:05 p.m.), Kathleen Meads (alternate)

Members absent:  None

Other attendees:  DPW Staff Dana Faris and Anna Michaud; members of the public and press.  

Call to Order

Mr. Sinaiko called the meeting to order at 3:00 p.m.

Public Hearing – Amendment to Sewer Regulations

Mr. Sinaiko read the announcement and opened the hearing to the public.  Mr. Faris explained that, because there are new vendors that offer better and less expensive solutions to grease management, the purpose of the rule change was to provide the Water & Sewer Board with greater latitude to approve grease traps using newer technology.  There were no speakers either in favor or in opposition to the rule change.  DPW staff reported that no letters had been received either in favor or in opposition to the proposed rule change.  Therefore, Mr. Sinaiko moved, seconded by Ms. Meads, to amend the sewer rules as advertised.  The motion carried by a vote of 3-0.

[At this point Mr. Van Dereck joined the meeting.]

Public Hearing – Change in Sewer Connection Surcharge Rate

Mr. Sinaiko read the announcement and opened the hearing to the public.  There were no speakers from the public either in favor or in opposition to the proposed rate increase.  Staff reported that no letters had been received either in favor or in opposition.  Ms. Meads moved, seconded by Mr. Sinaiko, to increase the Phase 1 sewer connection surcharge from $39.08 to $45.00, effective October 1, 2007.  The motion carried by a vote of 4-0.  Mr. Faris advised that, pursuant to MGL c. 40, §22F, before the rate change may take effect, it must be ratified by the Board of Selectmen, which is the Water & Sewer Board’s appointing authority.

Recommendation to Appoint Representative to PLOG

Mr. Sinaiko moved, seconded by Mr. Richter, to recommend that the Board of Selectmen appoint Kathleen Meads as the Water & Sewer Board representative to the Pamet Lens Oversight Group (PLOG).  The motion carried by a vote of 4-0.

Appeal of Phase 2 Betterment – 25 Winthrop St.

Attorney Chris Snow entered his appearance on behalf of the petitioner and stated that he relied on the arguments set forth in his letter to the Board dated June 14, 2007.  After some discussion, Mr. Sinaiko moved, seconded by Mr. Richter, to take the matter under advisement and to seek an opinion from town counsel.  The motion carried by a vote of 4-0.

Appeal of Phase 2 Betterment – 62 Franklin St.

Attorney Edward Patten entered his appearance on behalf of the petitioner and stated that he relied on the arguments set forth in his letter to the Board dated July 3, 2007.  After a brief discussion, Mr. Van Dereck moved, seconded by Mr. Sinaiko, to take the matter under advisement and to seek an opinion from town counsel.  The motion carried by a vote of 4-0.

Application for Water Service – 148 Shore Road, North Truro

Donald Perry, owner of the subject property, spoke for the application, which had previously been approved by both the Truro Board of Health and Truro Board of Selectmen.  Staff presented a statement from Water Superintendent Carl Hillstrom that he had reviewed the application and determined that it conformed to water regulations.  Therefore, Mr. Sinaiko moved, seconded by Mr. Van Dereck, to grant the application for new water service. 

Deferral of Water Charges

Mr. Faris presented the following application for deferral of water charges.  The applicant qualifies for deferral of real estate taxes and has entered into a deferral and recovery agreement.

Acct#

Address

 

Service

Amount Deferred

3808

16 West Vine St.

Water

$50.00

Mr. Sinaiko moved, seconded by Mr. Richter, to grant the deferral.  The motion carried by a vote of 4-0.

Abatements

Ms. Michaud presented the following applications for abatement of water usage:

Acct#

Property Address

Applicant

 Usage

 Bill Amount

Staff Recommendation

8307

10 Atlantic Ave., Units A & B

Lucille Hamilton

89,000

$825.50

No leak detected.  Old meter changed out and bench tested.  New meter didn’t disclose any leaks.  No recommendation.

Ms. Hamilton spoke for her application.  After some discussion, Mr. Sinaiko moved, seconded by Ms. Meads, to apply the 500% rule and abate the bill to $487.50.  The motion carried by a vote of 4-0.

Acct#

Property Address

Applicant

 Usage

 Bill Amount

Staff Recommendation

2518

9 Pearl St.

Lee Farroba

41,000

$182.00 - Water

$758.50 - sewer

No leak detected.  Old meter was stuck and was changed out.  Doesn’t qualify for 500% rule.  Recent readings show consumption of approximately 6,500 gals/month.  No recommendation.

Mrs. Farroba was present to speak for her application.  After some discussion, Mr. Sinaiko moved, seconded by Ms. Meads, (1) to base charges for the four-month off-peak period on consumption of 26,000 gallons and to abate the water charges to $105.00 and the sewer charges to $481.00, (2) to request that the Water Department continue to periodically monitor meter readings at this property, and (3) to recommend that the homeowner relocate the water meter to a more accessible location.  The motion carried by a vote of 4-0.

Ms. Michaud then presented the remaining abatement applications.

Acct#

Property Address

Applicant

 Usage

 Bill Amount

Staff Recommendation

5411

466 Commercial St.

John Beauchamp

128,000

$1,405.50 – water

Application filed after statutory deadline.  Also does not meet 500% rule.  Recommend denial.

19110

386 Commercial St. Holding Co.

Jerome Scally

398,000

$5,725.50 – water

$7,373.00 – sewer

Does not meet 500% rule.  Recommend denial.

9110

386 Commercial St. Holding Co.

Jerome Scally

271,000

$3,693.50 – water

$5,013.50 – sewer

In August 2006 it was discovered that meter was put in backwards.  Installation corrected.  Usage verified as correct.  Recommend denial.

1201

6 School St.

Mark E. Robinson

30,000

$162.50

Overcharged due to high estimate.  Reading problem has been corrected.  Recommend abatement to $50.

1280

357 Commercial St.

Victoria Yenadios

0

$75 – sewer

Not connected to sewer until after billing period.  Recommend abatement in full.

6804

227R Commercial St.

H. Bradford Rose

 

 

Overcharged due to estimates for several years when meter could not be read.  Problem has been corrected.  Abate $200.

7618

41 Court St.

Warren Silva

130,000

$865.00 – water

Clerical error at change-out.  Recommend abatement to $145.00

Mr. Sinaiko moved, seconded by Ms. Meads to accept the staff recommendations.  The motion carried by a vote of 4-0.

Flow Revision

Mr. Faris presented the following flow revision:

Map & Parcel

Address

Orig Flow

Rev Flow

Net Chg

Original Betterment

Revised Total Betterment

Net Betterment Increase (Decrease)

Reason for Change

12-2-014

389-393 Commercial St.

770

793

23

$25,933.60

$26,708.24

$774.60

Revision to reflect reduction of bedrooms from 7 to 6 and inclusion of 2,660 sf of retail space.

Mr. Sinaiko moved, seconded by Mr. Van Dereck, to revise the flow and betterment for this property.  The motion carried by a vote of 4-0.

Recommit Delinquent Water and Sewer Bills

Mr. Faris presented a list from the tax collector of uncollected delinquent water and sewer bills.  Mr. Sinaiko moved, seconded by Mr. Richter, to recommit the charges to the Board of Assessors for inclusion on the real estate bills.  The motion carried by a vote of 4-0.

Other Business

Mr. Faris presented a letter from the Board of Health recommending that properties under an ACO be given preference to any available sewer gallons within the Phase 1 service area.  The Board also inquired about the status of the public restroom signs.

Approval of Minutes

Ms. Meads moved, seconded by Mr. Sinaiko, to approve as printed the minutes of the meeting of June 21, 2007.  The motion carried by a vote of 4-0.

Adjournment

There being no further business, Mr. Sinaiko moved, seconded by Mr. Richter, to adjourn the meeting.  The vote carried by a vote of 4-0, and the meeting was adjourned at 4:15 p.m.

 

Respectfully submitted,

 

 

__________________________

Sacha Richter, Clerk