Provincetown
Historical Commission
Meeting of
November 6, 2002, 9:00 AM
Members Present: John Dowd, Ardis Markarian,
Stephen Milkewicz, Lawrence Riley, and Austin Knight
Excused
Absence:
Roger Keene
Town Hall Representative: Maxine Notaro, Permit
Coordinator and John Gilmore, Director of Community Development
There
was a work session from 9:00 until 9:30 AM.
There
was a general discussion of the cases to be presented at this meeting.
John
Dowd called the regular meeting to order at 9:30 AM.
Old Business
Case #2001-039 John Yingling, 190 Commercial Street. Replace
front door.
Ardis Markarian stated that she had spoken to John Yingling and new doors are ordered. They will be “P-town” doors.
New
Business
Case
#2002-072 Kevin Wynne on behalf of
the owner, Anne Welles, 12 Bradford Street, [Map/Parcel 06-4-072; MHC #1355;
Historic Name: Side Hall Cottage with Side Ell; Date: 1850-1870; 1920-1940;
Style: Astylistic Victorian sash & porch] Remove and replace existing siding.
Remove and replace storm windows and doors. Replace two windows on front of
house. Replace kitchen windows with thermo pane windows and repair any trim
before painting house.
It
was moved to approve this plan as presented.
Motion by: Ardis Markarian Seconded by: Austin Knight Vote: 5-0-0
Case
#2002-073 James J. and Anne
McDermott, 23 Bradford Street, [Map/Parcel 6-4-127; MHC #1320; Historic Name:
Cottage; Date: pre-1900, 1988; Style: Astylistic, sash & siding] Tear down rear part of house
and rebuild close to existing footprint (existing has code and life safety
issues). Front portion on Bradford Street to remain. Rebuild decks; relocate
exterior shower and oil
take inside rebuilt structure.
It
was moved to approve the plan with the following conditions:
1.
Will
keep kitchen (East) skylight but eliminate Western skylights
2.
Windows
will be 2/2 (replacement)
3.
Shed
roof over doors
4.
Pull
post out to corner of new deck (rear)
5.
Window
at end top peak (new addition) will be 2/2
6.
Captured
balusters on all decks
7.
New
chimney will be brick, or brick veneer, or parged.
Motion by: Ardis Markarian Seconded by: Stephen Milkewicz Vote: 5-0-0
Case
#2002-074 Patricia Warren and Pam
Nolan on behalf of John Aho, Jr., 22 Pearl Street, [Map/Parcel 12-3-60; MHC
#None; Historic Name: Central chimney ¾ cottage; Date: c 1800-1830, 1850-1870;
Style: Timber frame, Victorian porch, entry & sash] Demolish existing deck
and install new frame and decking. Repair existing posts.
It
was moved to approve as presented.
Motion by: Lawrence Riley Seconded by: John Dowd Vote: 4-0-1
(Austin Knight abstained)
Case
#2002-075 Neal Kimball on behalf
of Michael DiNapoli, 12 Court Street, [Map/Parcel 7-2-148; MHC #1147; Historic
Name: Central chimney, ¾ cottage; Date: 1820-1850; Style: Timber frame, Greek
revival entry]
Remove small bedroom on West side of structure, replace with 1½ story room
with loft storage area, add bath.
It was moved to accept the plans as presented with the following
conditions:
1.
Left
side (South) will have 2 double hung windows – 2/2
2.
French
doors will have one vertical muntin instead of 2. The trim on the top of the
French doors will be “beefed up.”
Motion by: Lawrence Riley Seconded by: John Dowd Vote: 4-0-1
(Austin Knight abstained)
The
minutes of October 16th were approved.
Lawrence
Riley suggested that the work session should be moved to end of meeting for
consideration of members. A discussion ensued. The Board will look into the
problem of approving an application and then finding that the client has made
other changes. This would require monitoring.
There
was a general discussion regarding a letter from the Massachusetts Historic
Commission about 139 Commercial Street. The Board could do nothing about this
until it is brought to them as a Case.
A
motion was made to adjourn the meeting at 11:00 AM.
Motion by: Ardis Markarian Seconded by: Lawrence Riley Vote: 4-0-1
Respectfully Submitted
Joel
Glasser
Approved
by: ________________________________________ on _______________________
John
Dowd, Chair Date